How data and social media are transforming investigative journalism in China

If you put “investigative journalism + China” in Google search bar, you will probably be disappointed with the few results it returns. There is a book about it <Investigative Journalism in China: Eight Cases in Chinese Watchdog Journalism>, which I read a few years ago and would still recommend. For the English-reading world, there is really limited information about this important topic. Even if your Chinese is good enough to perform a search, you will again be surprised about how few relevant results you can get.

It’s not an indication that investigative journalism is dead in China. Though it is indeed declining – check out an article I wrote for IJNet back in 2011 – China’s next brain drain: investigative journalists, or a more recent one on the same issue in 2013 –中国第一代调查记者“触顶”转型. My friends who used to work as investigative journalists in China have been flocking to other industries – many started their own business (check out this recent articles in Chinese 亚洲周刊|胡泳:新媒體創業風起雲湧爭奪話語權, published earlier this year), some turn to non-profit (Deng Fei for example), and some just retired to open their guesthouses and enjoy life.

However, for those who stay and continue to fight, China remains a gold mine for investigative stories, with lots of pressing issues – environmental crisis, government/Party corruption, judicial injustice, public health, money laundering (case of Bank of China and case of UnionPay ), among others. Yet, new technologies and powerful social media are providing new opportunities and helping stories reach broader audience and win greater social impact.

A recent example is an investigative documentary about air pollution by Ms Chai Jing, a former China Central Television reporter. She quit her job, led a team, spent 1 million RMB (around 160,000 USD) and made this film, basically trying to answer three questions: What is PM2.5? Where does it come from? How to solve the problem? Watch the film here – with English subtitles (crowdsourced by Chinese watchers, and led by a high-school final year student):

The film, entitled <Under the Dome>, went viral since it launched on March 1, 2015. Within 3 days, it reached 200 million hits. It is a TED-style talk, mixed with traditional TV interviews with credible sources, international reporting (she went to UK and US to learn experiences and practices from London and Los Angeles), drone shooting the factories (though failed because the pollution was too serious), data and charts as an effort to make sense of the abstract numbers, social network visualization of the corruptions within the environment and energy power system, and even animation to illustrate how PM2.5, a harmful micro-particle in pollutants, can invade human bodies and cause irreversible harm. It is not perfect – lots of public debates are around the way it tells the story and the facts and data, but it successfully leveraged all the technologies and presentation formats that is available now and made the film really powerful.

Another example is a series of stories around Zhou Yongkang, the most senior Party official caught in the anti-corruption campaign last year. Carried out by a 9-person team at Caixin, one of the most reputable media organization in China, the investigation took 1 year and a 60,000-word piece was delivered, some of which are translated into English.

It is solid reporting, but how many people would still sit down and read through the 60K words? So Caixin’s Data Visualization Lab produced an interactive visualization to illustrate the people and companies connected with Zhou – English version here, note it’s designed differently from the Chinese version below. This project received 4 million hits, according to Huang Zhimin, the CTO of Caixin and the head of the Data Visualization Lab.

财新_周永康_updated

In some other cases, investigations are not done by professional journalists or media organizations, but ordinary citizens. Interestingly, you don’t hear the term “citizen journalism” in China now, at least not as much as you would a few years ago. But that doesn’t mean that’s dead. Quite the opposite – with the popularity of social media, everyone provides information and the pieces would quickly come together. A well-known example is the “watch brother“, a local official whose photos of wearing luxury watches were spotted by social media detectives and all the brands (Bulgari, Omega and Rolex, to name a few) and even some of the models were identified. He was later investigated and sent to jail for 14 years.

<Under the Dome> was taken down from Chinese video platforms after surviving online for only 7 days. However, an app about pollution that was mentioned in the documentary hit top 1 in the app store and reached 3 million users. It does not only take data from the Ministry of Environment and make them more readable, but also has a crowdsourcing function where users can report factories that are disposing pollutants. Within March, over 300 factories were reported and had to rectify.

weilan_2weilan_4

Changes are happening, with the help of more open data and better presentations. There are still lots of challenges and risks for doing investigative journalism in China. Censorship is exercised online and offline. Surveillance is by default, internal and externalMedia institutions are declining, same as everywhere else in the world.  But despite of all the difficulties, continuous efforts are being made – always as a collaboration between media organizations, civil society, and individual citizens, and it’s important to keep it going.

This post is based on part of my sharing at the IPI World Congress in Myanmar, March 2015, on the panel of “The Need for Investigative Journalism in Free Society”. Panel photo credit: Rajneesh Bhandari

特此感谢友人石头于我此行所提供的专业建议及支持鼓励。

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: